What’s a Canadian Citizenship good for anyway?

with one comment

In the 1970’s the Black Panthers, the Weather Underground and many other black power and student movements turned to violence, kidnapping and bombings in their struggle against, among other things, the Vietnam war. The US government fought these movements (often illegally) with police forces and the judicial system.

In the 1970’s the Front de Libération du Québec, a group of canadian students turned to violence and kidnappings in their struggle against, among other things, discrimination against french-canadians. The Canadian government unilaterally suspended all civil rights of all residents of the province of Québec, arrested without warrant hundreds of citizens and sent the army in the streets of Montréal.

What good are rights that can be unilaterally suspended as they were in the case of Canadians of Italian, German and Japanese descent during the world wars? Or as they were in the Province of Québec in 1970?

A few years ago the Royal Canadian Mounted Police assisted the United States in illegally transferring Maher Arar to an axis of evil, Syria, where he was tortured. Omar Khadr’s has spent the last 5 years in Guantanamo awaiting military trial as an enemy combatant. His Canadian passport has not been of much use to him in Guantanamo. If he had an American passport he would have been allowed a lawyer and a trial in a US jurisdiction where the constitution applies.

This week we learn that a Canadian citizenship doesn’t even mean you are allowed to work in Canada. In a Montreal Gazette editorial published on december 26th we learn that Canadian companies who have contracts with the United States Military are not allowed to hire Canadians if they happen also hold the citizenship of such countries as Haïti, Venezuela, Cuba and Iran.

The companies who have these military contracts and who therefore enforce the US State department rules are Bombardier, SNC-Lavallin, Pratt & Whitney Canada and Bell Helicopter Textron. The companies that are legally allowed to discriminate against Canadian citizens are all massively subsidized by all levels of government.

Omar Khadr, Maher Arar and all those of us who happen to hold dual citizenship with countries that the United States government doesn’t like would have more rights and protections if we were US citizens than we do as Canadians.

So what’s a Canadian passport good for anyway?

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. The only way this thing is ever going to work is to take the MPs right out of it. As the speaker pntoied out, there are faults on both sides, but unless you completely remove all taint of partisanship, it will be a waste of time.There is really no compelling reason that MPs should see the documents. They are not particularly trained in deciding what may or may not be sensitive, and are simply going to be looking at the information from one perspective their own.Then there is the simple question of the time it will take. About 10,000 redacted documents have been released, and there are more to come. It was apparently going to take Iaccobucci 18 months to two years. Somehow I think MPs should have more to do than spend the next year or so going through piles of documents.If MPs are not involved, then it solves the problem with what to do about the Bloc. Yes, they are legally elected MPs, but they are dedicated to the break-up of this country, they don’t support the National Anthem or the Maple Leaf, and I think you would have to be brain dead to give them this kind of opportunity.Swearing in MPs is meaningless because if an MP reads these secret documents, and subsequently stands up in Question Period and raises an issue from one of them, since he will be under parliamentary privilege, there will be no penalty. There is also the innuendo card as in , Gee Tom/Evan, I have to tell you that some of the stuff I read is deeply disturbing, but I swore an oath of secrecy . The most sensible solution would be to amend the instructions to Iaccobucci and have him report to Parliament, or even a special Parliamentary Committee. Unfortunately, I think nothing less than a lynching will satisfy the Bloc and the NDP who now smell blood. It remains to be seen if the Liberals can restrain themselves.


    January 19, 2013 at 1:25 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: